30 + Recipes for the Super Bowl

Growing up in the old order Amish and then Mennonite communities, we never watched football. While we were Old Order Amish, having a tv was strictly forbidden and if you were caught with one, you were put under the “ban” and shunned until the allotted time of “repentance” was fulfilled. Sneaking over to the neighbors to watch football on their television, wasn’t exactly encouraged either, so I grew up knowing absolutely nothing about football, the rules of the game, or even Super bowl parties until I meant my husband who is an avid Dallas Cowboys fan. Now I somewhat root for the Kansas City Chiefs (I like watching Mahome’s trick shots) and pretend to know what’s going on at a Super Bowl party, but let’s be real, I’m really only involved for the food. 🙂 Below is a list of our family favorite snack ideas for the Super bowl, and hopefully you will find some tasty options to add to your Super Bowl snack board!

1. Slow Cooker Buffalo Chicken Dip

Easy crockpot Buffalo Chicken Dip

This easy slow cooker buffalo chicken dip is a delicious option with a hint of spice from the buffalo sauce. Perfect for dipping breads, pretzels, crackers, chips and more into!

2. Amish Soft Pretzels Recipe

Amish soft pretzels like Auntie Annes

Amish soft pretzels have been a long time family favorite. These pillowy soft pretzels made with yeast, are perfect for snacking on while watching the big game!

3. Amish cheese sauce (“shmear Kaes”)

Amish cup spread (Church cheese spread)

In my opinion, no soft pretzel, or even snack board is complete without this simple cheese sauce that was a main staple of the Amish community we grew up in. This cheese sauce is great for dipping any soft pretzels, breadsticks, or salties into!

4. Slow Cooker Pizza Dip

Easy Crockpot Pizza Dip only 6 ingredients

This simple cream cheese based pizza dip is the perfect centerpiece of the snack board for pizza lovers! Try dipping bread sticks, crackers, pretzels, tortilla chips and more into this pizza dip for a deliciously savory pizza experience.

5. Copycat Olive garden Breadsticks

Copycat Olive Garden Breadsticks

If you want a side with extra pizzazz to impress your company, be sure to give these copycat Olive Garden breadsticks a go! Perfect to pair with pizza, soup, cheese sauce, pizza dip and so much more.

6. Easy Sloppy Joes (Slow Cooker or Skillet)

Easy Sloppy Joe Recipe

These easy sloppy joes are perfect to toss into the slow cooker and are made with the best, sweet and tangy homemade barbeque sauce!

7. Crockpot Barbequed Chicken Wings

Easy Barbequed Wings Slow Cooker

These barbequed wings with an easy homemade barbeque sauce are perfect for popping into your slow cooker in time to be ready for watching the big game.

8. Seafood Cheese Ball

Seafood Cheese ball (with old bay seasoning)

For seafood lovers, this cream cheese ball with Old bay seasoning, shrimp and crab, is the ultimate snack centerpiece! We love munching on this seafood cheeseball with Ritz crackers, pretzels, tortilla chips and more.

9. Soft Pretzel Garlic Knots

Amish Garlic pretzel knots

Soft and buttery pretzel knots with a garlic butter topping are a popular recipe for a reason, they are just that good! These pretzel knots are perfect if you plan on having pizza and wings or even chili at your game day party.

10. Zesty Homemade Guacamole

Zesty homemade guacamole

If you are in the mood for a heathier dipping option for the big game, try this zesty homemade Guacamole with delicious Mexican flavors incorporated into it!

11. Amish Butter Ranch Seasoned Pretzels

Amish Butter Ranch Seasoned Pretzels

This Amish recipe for seasoned butter Ranch pretzels are a great option for the Super bowl, because they can be made a day or more ahead of time and add extra flavor and fun to the table.

12. Crockpot Crab Stuffed Mushrooms

Crab stuffed Mushrooms crock pot or baked

3 cheese crab stuffed mushrooms with Cajun seasoning and Old Bay are a great appetizer to toss into the oven or slow cooker for game day!

13. Easy Baked Pizza Sliders

Easy Pizza Sliders with garlic butter topping

These delicious pizza sliders are an excellent finger food for foot ball watching. Made with a buttery parmesan and herb topping, and stuffed with sauce, cheese, pepperoni and salami, these pizza sliders will have everyone going for seconds!

14. Soft Pretzel Pigs in a Blanket

Amish pigs in a pretzel blanket

These pigs in a blanket with Amish soft pretzel dough are one of my top picks for a super bowl party, or really, any party! The homemade soft pretzel dough is the perfect “blanket” for these little piggies. We love dipping our pretzel pigs in a blanket into honey mustard or Amish cup cheese spread.

15. Veggie and Mozzarella Crostini

Veggie and pesto mozzarella crostini

Veggie and Mozzarella Crostini are an elegant finger food to serve for your party. The veggie, pesto and cheese topping on slices of crusty French bread are a delicious appetizer/snack option!

16. Ham sliders with Poppy Seed Topping

Ham and cheese sliders with poppy seed sauce

These ham and cheese sliders are slathered in a deliciously buttery poppy seed sauce and make a delicious finger food that no one will be able to resist!

17. Fresh Cucumber Salsa

Fresh and zesty cucumber salsa

This zesty cucumber salsa is made with fresh ingredients and a hint of spice from the jalapenos (which can be omitted). Another great option if you are looking to add some healthier options to your Super Bowl food board.

18. Mozzarella Stuffed Meatballs

Mozzarella stuffed meatballs made in the crockpot.

These mozzarella stuffed meatballs are made with only basic ingredients, and can be baked or made in the slow cooker. Serve these meatballs with sub rolls for a delicious meatball sub that everyone can enjoy!

19. Amish Peanut Butter Spread

Amish Peanut butter spread

This fluffy peanut butter spread with marshmallow cream and several more ingredients, is a delicious sweet dip for pretzels, fruit and even bread! An Amish family favorite that is always loved in my home.

20. Jalapeno Popper Zucchini Boats

Jalapeno Popper Zucchini Boats

These 7 ingredient Jalapeno popper boats are stuffed with cheese, jalapeno bits, bacon and seasonings. Another great finger food option for spice lovers!

21. Amish 3 Ingredient Ham Salad

3 ingredient Amish ham salad

3 ingredient ham salad is a great prep ahead option if you wish to serve sandwiches at your game day party. You can grill the ham salad sandwiches similar to grilled cheese, serve the sandwiches plain, or even use the ham salad as a dip for salties!

22. Homemade Sheet Pan Pizza

If you want to serve pizza for your game day party, but wish to avoid the greasiness of take-out pizza, then this homemade sheet pan pizza is a great option for you! The best part about homemade pizza is that it can be customized to your preference.

23. Sheet Pan Sweet Potato Fries

Crispy sweet potato fries with dipping sauce

These crispy sweet potato fries are a delicious finger food snack that is perfect for French fry lovers. The best part about these sweet potato fries is that they can be made at home with only basic ingredients!

24. Amish Haystacks (aka Taco Salad)

Amish haystacks dinner

Amish haystacks are similar to taco salad, and a great option for feeding a crowd with the customizable topping options. Add your favorite meats, cheeses, veggies and sauces for a memorable Super bowl snack/dinner.

25. Homemade Stromboli

Make your own stromboli with this delicious homemade stromboli dough that happens to also be an Amish family favorite! Homemade stromboli is a great option for game day if you are looking for a more filling finger food option to feed your tribe.

26. Roasted Ranch Potatoes

Oven roasted bacon and ranch potatoes

These oven roasted potatoes with ranch, parmesan, bacon and more are a very flavorful side dish that makes a nice and filling appetizer for a party. These Ranch potatoes are easy to compile and roasted to crisp perfection!

27. Chocolate Chip Cookies

No snack table is complete without a handful of sweets gracing it. Chocolate chip cookies are a crowd pleasing choice, especially these soft cookies from my Amish grandmother’s recipe collection!

28. Chunky M&M Cookies

Chunky M&M Cookies Gramma's Amish recipe collection

These loaded chunky M&M cookies from my Amish grandmother’s recipe collection are another crowd pleasing cookie, and the best part about these chunky M&M cookies, is that they can be made Gluten Free!

29. Peanut butter Blossom Bars

These soft peanut butter blossom bars are even easier to make than cookies, and are the perfect, indulgent treat to make for chocolate and peanut butter lovers!

30. Amish Fruit Pizza Cookies

Easy Amish Fruit pizza cookies

These Amish fruit pizza cookies with a cream cheese icing and a shortbread base are a pretty pop of color (and flavor) to add to your Super Bowl spread!

31. Bacon Cheddar Ranch Jalapeno Poppers

Bacon Cheddar Ranch Jalapeno Poppers

These Jalapeno poppers with Ranch, bacon and cheddar are a delicious appetizer, especially if you love the heat of jalapenos and the crispiness of the bacon wrapped around them!

32. Amish Molasses Cookies

These soft and chewy Amish molasses cookies with a drizzle of white chocolate would be very easy to decorate like little football cookies for the big game!

And that’s a wrap of snack ideas for the big game. Hope you enjoy your Super Bowl party with lots of friends, family and good food. May the best man (team) win!

Privacy Policy

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top